I heard it will be on the Fediverse. Is it true? I heard it had 30 millions users registered on the first day. Wtf. The whole Fediverse doesn’t even have 10 millions users. I heard it will not be available in Europe, yet. I visited https://www.threads.net/ and I don’t know if it’ll be the Threads instance to the Fediverse. There’s nothing at the moment.
I wouldn’t like this contamination in the Fediverse. What are your thoughts?
The only reason Threads has 30 million users right off the bat is because they leveraged their monopoly position with Instagram to push their users to Threads. It is absolutely no different from how Microsoft leveraged their monopoly position with Windows to push their users to Internet Explorer in the 90s.
Facebook has a long history of buying out any firm which poses the threat of competition. Peter Theil, the literal fucking vampire who sits on their board, has made very blunt remarks about this. They bought out Instagram and WhatsApp for this very reason. Make no mistake. To Facebook, the Fediverse is competition. Every minute spent on Lemmy, Mastodon, PixelFed, and other AGPL federated platforms is a minute lost from the commercial attention economy. Every user who makes the switch is a user which isn’t feeding them a steady stream of marketing data. Every user who makes the switch is lost ad revenue.
Facebook cannot buy the Fediverse the same way they bought Instagram. Instead, they will join it and apply incredible pressure to influence it in directions which are not harmful to their bottom line, and once the threat is neutralized, they will drop it like a hot turd. It could’t be any more obvious what their intentions are, but a lot of the tech bro dipshits still think a “wait and see” approach is warranted, including Eugen (initial creator of Mastodon) himself.
This guy made a blog post this morning saying that Mastodon is different from XMPP. XMPP was only used by a bunch of nerds and that’s why it died. It had nothing to do with Google employing the classic “Embrace, Extend, Extinguish” strategy. Meanwhile like 75% of people on Mastodon have their fucking Linux distro in their bio (gentoo gang, btw).
We might have gotten lucky with a handful of these “Benevolent Dictators For Life,” but only WE can create a network which is liberating and empowering. Nobody is going to deliver it for us.
My problem is, I don’t fully understand how to defederate from it.
For example, if I subscribe to a community on an instance that isn’t defederate from Threads, and I post there, am I handing my data to Threads. I don’t understand where the line is at which my data is protected from Threads.
That is a serious problem for me that would make me stop using the fediverse.
Federation is managed at an instance level, by the administrators of that instance. Instances can take either an accept-list approach or a block-list approach. As an end user, you choose to de-federate from it by choosing an instance which de-federates from it (or by running your own instance). The moderation / personal block tools on Lemmy aren’t as sophisticated right now as they are on Mastodon, but ideally you should also be able to personally block instances from accessing your account as well.
A lot of third party communication occurs on the Fediverse though. If a community is hosted on server A, you come from server B, and another user comes from server C, it is reasonable to ask if server A will just hand server B’s content (replies, votes, etc.) to server C. On Mastodon, this is the default behavior, unless an instance enables the “Authorized Fetch” option. I am not sure how this works on Lemmy.
For the meantime though, Threads is focused on the microblogging format of social media, and compatibility with Mastodon in particular. Lemmy is probably less at risk. But you should still treat every public post like it is truly public. People run scrapers. People run bots. People can take snapshots on archive.org. Federated platforms are no different in this regard.
Your posts and comments are public. Anything you post to an instance that is not defederated with Threads can and will show up on Threads. Consider anything you post to pretty much be public domain (yes, even artists who post their pictures should be careful). Nothing is stopping anyone from taking a screencap of your content and posting it there either (this isn’t new). The best course of action is to message the admins of your instance and tell them how you feel about Threads. Tell them to defederate and never look back.
Yes, but taking a screenshot is not even close to being the same as scraping my data.
They’ll scrape this and get a JSON returned with the text. Its technically different but the end result is the same in the context of posts on lemmy.
error loading comment
DEFEDERATE
deleted by creator
defederation.
It has made me feel like I am going to be giving up on most of the world.
When the likes of Facebook, Instagram, Twitter came out the world was still learning about privacy, and the companies took it away in baby steps. People were already using it and addicted, so I can understand why they didn’t give it up.
This, however, is a new service by fucking Zuckerberg. I honestly think you have got to have something deeply wrong with your cognitive functions to sign up for a new service from that man.
For me, it concerns me that I am going to have to go out of my way to find instances that defederate from it, which is going to be a pain in the ass.
defederation. only way I feel
I would prefer that we all de-federate from any corporations. If they are federated they will certainly be slurping up EVERYTHING they can touch, whether or not it’s on their instance. As far as the 30m users, I’m pretty sure anyone with an Instagram account automatically has a threads account so the numbers are inflated from the amount of people actually using it.
Edit: I was wrong about the Instagram=Threads account thing. I still don’t believe those numbers though.
If you’re from the UK, “Threads” is known as an oddly scary TV movie that messed up many a child who watched it. So it’s already synonymous with end times.
We could call Meta’s new app “threats” 😅
Full disclosure: I’ve never had a Twitter account and have never really been interested in one, though I’ve clicked links to Twitter content in the past.
A lot of people are understandably looking for a Twitter alternative, and some may go to threads because it’s not Elon, and they may have had good experiences with Instagram. But I would never in a million years make an account on Threads. Zuckerberg may not be overtly incompetent like Elon, but I think his products (especially Facebook) have been responsible for some terrible things, and I think they have egregious practices with personal data.
I hope something less susceptible to corporate takeover and monetization, like mastodon, takes off.
Threads was a great SG1 episode
