Does AI actually help students learn? A recent experiment in a high school provides a cautionary tale.
Researchers at the University of Pennsylvania found that Turkish high school students who had access to ChatGPT while doing practice math problems did worse on a math test compared with students who didn’t have access to ChatGPT. Those with ChatGPT solved 48 percent more of the practice problems correctly, but they ultimately scored 17 percent worse on a test of the topic that the students were learning.
A third group of students had access to a revised version of ChatGPT that functioned more like a tutor. This chatbot was programmed to provide hints without directly divulging the answer. The students who used it did spectacularly better on the practice problems, solving 127 percent more of them correctly compared with students who did their practice work without any high-tech aids. But on a test afterwards, these AI-tutored students did no better. Students who just did their practice problems the old fashioned way — on their own — matched their test scores.
Unsurprised
I.would have no problem with AI if the shit actually worked
No, I think the point here is that the kids never learned the material, not that AI taught them the wrong material (though there is a high possibility of that).
Yes yet there is indeed a deeper point. If the AI is to be used as a teaching tool it still has to give genuinely useful advice. No good sounding advice that might actually still be wrong. LLMs can feed wrong final answers but they can also make poor suggestions on the process itself too. So there are both problematic, how the tool is used but also its intrinsic limitations.